Granholm vs. Heald

May 16 was the Tenth Anniversary of Granholm vs. Heald and it was a wonderful decision for all wine lovers in the states of Michigan and New York. The case was argued in the United States Supreme Court on December 7, 2004 and decided on May 16, 2005. Eleanor Heald and her husband were wine collectors and they also had a syndicated wine column that was carried in some of the local Michigan newspapers. Jennifer Granholm was at the time Governor of the State of Michigan and she was part of the political machine from Wayne County.

Third Party Shipper

What was going on in Michigan was that the wine distributing industry was curtailing the rights of individuals to secure wines for their personal consumption. If the distributors did not carry a wine brand, then the wine could not legally enter the state, and it is a very strong political lobby to this day. The state had granted allowances to Michigan wineries to be able to ship their product directly to consumers, because they were trying to build up the fledgling wine industry in the state, but they denied outside wineries from the same competition.

Michigan was regarded as a “Felony” state to wineries and they would not even attempt to ship wine to Michigan. I remember the old days, and how a winery owner explained to me, how to have wine shipped home. The winery could sell me wine, but they could not ship the wine. Once I had bought the wine, it was my own personal property and after it had left the grounds of the winery, the winery had no further interest in the product. I could then legally take the wine to third party independent shipper, one that handled and expedited wine shipments and I could have my property shipped back to myself after purchasing special shipping cartons for the conveyance of all the bottled liquids. I also took the further precaution of having them shipped to my place of business, had the packages marked as olive oil and then to ensure that an adult could sign for the shipment, if I was not there. Even then it felt only-quasi legal and that I was in effect skirting the law, which big political machines have been doing on the sly for years.

Direct Shipping

Since this case has been decided, I can now receive wine shipments at home, and basically all I really get is wine from my wine club, but I am glad that it is has become legal in Michigan. Some states are still considered “Felony” states because of the wording of the laws in those states. I still have to sign for a wine delivery, which is fine, one has to be an adult (Age of Majority) to buy wine, so having an adult sign for wine is understandable and totally acceptable. The good news is that the special wine crates are reusable and can be shipped empty ahead of time to where ever I plan on staying, to be filled up again, for another shipment home. The other good news is that just like this bad law is no longer in effect; neither is Jennifer Granholm the Governor of the State of Michigan.

About thewineraconteur

A non-technical wine writer, who enjoys the moment with the wine, as much as the wine. Instagram/thewineraconteur Facebook/ The Wine Raconteur
This entry was posted in Uncategorized, Wine. Bookmark the permalink.

5 Responses to Granholm vs. Heald

  1. Yvette says:

    Yeah… remember, “and in 5 years you’ll be blown away!” I, too, am glad she’s gone.

  2. We used to have the same problem in New Hampshire. Glad that’s all over now!

  3. talkavino says:

    The wine is so over-regulated in his country, it is not funny. For instance, as an individual, I have no legal way of shipping the wine as a present – I have to find a wine store which will be willing to help me and essentially, ship the wine for me… Also wineries can’t ship directly to Connecticut – the wine always have to go through the three tier system to arrive here. Crazy!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.