I must admit that not having dinner at Butch’s when we are in Holland, Michigan would be a crime to both my Bride and me. There are less than 800 restaurants world-wide, and only ten in the State of Michigan that hold the Wine Spectator’s Best of Award of Excellence. They have a few suggested wine pairings on the menu, but the depth of wines is arranged like a store, and you select the bottles for your meal.

We arrived at the restaurant ahead of our reservation, did some wine shopping for dinner, as they were kind enough to let us see a menu, and we even sampled a couple of wines in the bar, for happy hour. My Bride and I shared an order of La Belle Farms Foie Gras, an appetizer of Seared Foie Gras, with Fig Marmalade, Pickled Fennel and Onion Herb Salad and Crostini. The dish is rich enough, that we can share it. We paired it with Chateau Doisy-Daene Sauternes-Barsac 2022 from Famille Denis Dubourdieu since 1924. It is a famed Grand Cru Classé Second Growth from the 1855 Classification of the Medoc and Graves. The estate was once part of a larger property which was divided into three individual chateaux in the mid-19th Century (the other two being Chateau Doisy-Vedrines and Doisy-Dubroca). The estate is eighteen hectares of vineyard. The Grand Vin is made from botrytis-affected grapes. The vines average about forty years of age and are planted on the Barsac plateau, a thin layer of “Barsac red sands” which is above the chalky subsoil of clay and limestone. The wine is ninety-five percent Semillon and five percent Sauvignon Blanc, and the grapes are collected slowly over weeks by bunches. The grapes undergo a phase of skin contact, then a slow juice extraction, using only the free run, and fermentation takes place in French Oak, of which only fifteen percent is new. It is aged in oak for ten months, followed by another nine months in Stainless-Steel and then bottled. The deep golden colored wine offered notes of mango, persimmon, apricot and yellow plum with additional notes of honeysuckle and jasmine, vanilla, lemon and orange peel. On the palate this medium-to-full bodied, well balance wine displayed tones of apricot, mango, peach and plum with spices blending with fresh acidity and ending with a long-count finish of fruit, florals and minerals.

My Bride had “Chili Fish” a dish of Whitefish, Lemongrass and Basmati Fried Rice, Peanut, Herb Salad. I had the Seared Hokkaido Scallops, Charred Leeks, Sweet Corn and Summer Truffle. We also enjoyed a bottle of Domaine Louis Moreau Chablis Vau Lingneau 1er Cru 2022. The Moreau family has been in Chablis since 1814, and Louis is now the sixth generation. Vau Lingneau is one of the westernmost Premier Cru vineyards in Chablis, just south of Beine and west of Chablis. Domaine Moreau has a ten-hectare parcel on calcareous and limestone layers and morning sun, ideal for Chardonnay and was last planted in 1976. After harvest the juice is fermented in Stainless-Steel tanks with indigenous yeasts for about eighteen days at cool regulated temperature, then Malolactic Fermentation for a couple of months, then resting on fine lees for at least six months, with the wine in the tank for at least eighteen months. This golden-yellow colored wine offered notes of pineapple and mint, followed by a trace of terroir. On the palate this medium-bodied, well-balanced wine displayed tones of tropical fruit blending with some bright acidity and ending with a fine long-count finish of fruit and terroir.

After dinner we enjoyed our decaf coffee and shared a dish of “Sticky Toffee Pudding” with Vanilla Bourbon, Medjool Dates and Crème Anglaise. We also had a glass of Fonseca Porto Ten-Year-Old Aged Tawny Port NV from Fonseca Guimaraens. Fonseca is a well-regarded Port house with three vineyard estates in the Douro region and the make the gamut of Port offerings from Reserve Ruby to Vintage Ports. Fonseca was founded in1815 by the Fonseca and Monteiro families, with the Guimaraens family taking over in the second half of the 19th Century. In 1949, the company was bought by Taylor, Fladgate & Yeatman, which had loaned Fonseca considerable sums since the outbreak of war in 1939. Despite the change of ownership, the house is run as a separate entity, and the Guimaraens family still have key positions to this day. There are roughly eighty grape varietals sanctioned in the production of Port, and some are truly lost both in name and in the vineyards over the centuries. After ten years, the wine has lost some of its deep red color and developed the “tawny” amber color, and the wine offers notes of ripe mature fruit, butterscotch, caramel, roasted nuts, and orange rind. On the palate this medium-to-full-bodied, well-balanced wine displayed tones of rich, complex mellow fruit blended with toffee, caramel, butterscotch, and spiced oranges, with oak tones, ending with a long-count finish of fruit and roasted almonds.


























