A St. Patrick’s Day Poser

I tend to write some of my stories ahead of time, when the muse strikes me.  I am just getting to a wine question that had me perplexed for the moment.  My Bride wanted to prepare a traditional Corned Beef and Cabbage dinner for St. Patrick’s Day.  That was fine with me, as I happen to enjoy Corned Beef for dinner, and also like it as hash with poached eggs for breakfast, so I was all set for a nice meal.  Then she posed a question to me “what wine are you going to get from the cellar?”

 

I ponder this question, as I did not want to make a snap decision.  At first I thought well it is beef, so I should grab a red wine.  As I went through some of my reds and ticked them off mentally, I was able to eliminate Cabernet Sauvignon, Merlot and Pinot Noir immediately; as I felt that these would overpower the dish.  I also thought about the condiments that we were going to use, horseradish and mustard, not to mention the cabbage which made me nix the above wines.  I then thought about a Malbec, Beaujolais and a Zinfandel and decided that these may be too fruity and sweet against the meal.  I also decided against my two standard go to wines, because I thought that a Montepulciano d’Abruzzo or a Rioja Reserva would not pair very well with the dinner.

Bowers Harbor Gewurztraminer Old Mission 2008

 

As I thought about it some more, I decided that perhaps I should entertain the thought of a white wine.  I dismissed a Riesling as too sweet, and a Pinot Grigio as too bland for the dish.  A Viognier, I thought would fight the dish, because of the usual flowery bouquet of a nose.  Then it hit me, that a Gewurztraminer would do the trick.  I like how this spicy tasting wine works with Asian-rim cuisine, and I thought that it would complement the condiments and I also thought that it could hold it’s own against even the cabbage.  All of this was working in my “mind’s eye.”  I went down to the cellar and searched for a bottle of Gewurztraminer from my rack of white wines.  I decided on a bottle from Bowers Harbor Vineyards 2008 from the Old Mission Peninsula near Traverse City in the northern part of Lower Michigan.  We had been to this winery several times, and each time, we always left with a few bottles of their Gewurztraminer as well as some of their other bottles of wine.   I chilled the wine in preparation of the dinner, opened it and pour without any fanfare.  Not only was I pleased with the selection for dinner, but my Bride was equally happy with it, and it was a pleasant wine to drink into the evening as well.

Unknown's avatar

About thewineraconteur

A non-technical wine writer, who enjoys the moment with the wine, as much as the wine. Twitter.com/WineRaconteur Instagram/thewineraconteur Facebook/ The Wine Raconteur
This entry was posted in Dining, Wine and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

6 Responses to A St. Patrick’s Day Poser

  1. I did pair with a Riesling (Kendall-Jackson) and it was great. Love to try your pick some time. Cheers!

    • I just imagined that most of the Riesling wines that I have in the cellar are bought with certain friends tastes in mind, and they may be a bit sweeter than the Kendall-Jackson, which I have not tried.
      That is what I enjoy about wines, the ideas and suggestions.

  2. It sounds like a rather classic pairing to me, so you went right down the right path. In Alsace, people eat choucroute which is tons of sauerkraut with loads and loads of meat (sausage, roasts, stewed). They pair it with either a Gewürztraminer or a dry Riesling. Chapeau!! And thanks for taking us through your elimination process. I always find that very helpful.

    • Oliver,
      Thank you for that insight. The Riesling wines in my cellar are domestic and were purchased for sweetness for some friends of ours that prefer that type of wine, that is why I did not attempt a Riesling from my cellar.
      I have really enjoyed some of the Gewurztraminer wines from Michigan, and I may suggest you try some as well, especially if you get a chance to go to the Traverse City area.
      – John

      • Oh, I will. To me, it is definitely one of the most difficult grapes to make wines with: so much aroma that it can easily be completely overpowering, yet not much acidity to give any latent sweetness balance…tough grape, but when made well, soooo good.

  3. Sounds like a great choice and dinner! Salud.

Leave a comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.